When You’re Headed to a (Broken) Home for the Holidays

*this post was originally written by Ashley for the Women’s Life blog at Southeastern Theological Seminary.

The crackling fire place, the stockings all lined up in a row, the smell of warm cider and a freshly trimmed Christmas tree.

These are the pictures that dance in our minds around the holidays.

Well, it’s the picture for some people.

But then there’s the rest of us whose picture is much less fanciful. There’s some of us on this side of Christmas who have a hard time going home.

We’re the ones who come from towns we’d rather not talk about, or families we are intentionally vague about when you ask us about our holiday plans. We’re the ones whose families have been plagued by divorce, addiction, adultery, lies, deceit, mental illness, fits of anger, abandonment, or abuse. We’re the ones who answer in blanket statements when you ask how so-and-so is, because you know what? So-and-so is having a hard time, and we have a hard time talking about it.

We’re the one’s whose Christmas picture is broken.

So what if you, like me, are traveling back to a broken home for the holidays? How should you prepare, react, respond?

If you are like me, you’ve probably developed some poor habits when you go home. Maybe you slip back into old, destructive patterns. Maybe you numb out and coast through the whole experience. Maybe you always blow up at that one family member who seems to make you crazy, even when you swore you wouldn’t react that way this time.

While I know everyone’s broken home is different, here’s one resounding lesson I’ve learned that applies to them all:


One of the crazy-good benefits of being a Christian is that our God is not far off and unfamiliar with our struggles.

Jesus Christ himself had a hard time when it came to his hometown. Can you remember? Mark 6:1-5 tells us that Nazareth wouldn’t take him seriously.

You mean Joseph and Mary’s kid? The carpenter? Yeah right, like he ever turned out to be anything good. Wasn’t she pregnant before they got married? 

It’s not a newsflash that a lot of people didn’t buy the whole “An angel appeared and Mary got pregnant by the Holy Spirit” thing. The people surrounding Jesus’ life looked at him and his family story like it was a joke, or worse, an abomination. Whispers and judgmental side-glances were probably part of Jesus’ entire upbringing.

And he somehow bore all of that without sinning.

Do you feel that way this holiday season? Do you always feel like you’re never taken seriously when you go back to that place? Do you feel like you’ll always be seen as that person you were when you were twelve? Do you hate going home because you know you’ll have to face people who have heard about the scandal that happened in your family?

You’re in good company, friend. The company of Christ himself.

Remember that Jesus’ birth story wasn’t the only scandal when it comes to his family. In Jewish tradition, you only included the important and swoon-worthy candidates in your genealogy. You made sure to throw in any royal bloodlines, or religious heroes. You left out anyone who could bring shame on the family. This was just the way genealogies were written. Only the best are remembered.

But Jesus? His entire genealogy in Matthew 1 was a chock-full mess of adulterers, drunks, murderers, prostitutes and the like. The fact that a Jewish author would mention any of these types of misfits, especially women, was unheard of.

The point?

Jesus knows what it’s like to come from a family story that you’re not proud of.

When it comes to family brokenness, Hebrews 4:15 tells us that our God doesn’t just understand what we’re dealing with on an intellectual level, but that he actually dealt with everything we deal with. He sympathizes because he’s been there. He gets it.

In other words, you serve a God who walked through it, too.

Do you know what Isaiah 53:3 tells you?

That God himself humbled himself to become a “man of sorrows, acquainted with our deepest grief.” Friend, that’s not just a nice Bible-phrase. That’s your hope, your anchor, your power to get through this holiday.

All the kinds of brokenness we see in this life, Jesus has seen and dealt with and become acquainted with. He doesn’t just understand our weaknesses as humans, he’s lived them for us.

But why? Why did Jesus even have to become familiar with our sorrows?

Because he knew we’d respond poorly amidst them. We have blown up, said things we shouldn’t, thought bad things, responded in anger, hidden from our issues, refused to forgive, and so on. There’s a multiplicity of ways we don’t respond well when we go home for the holidays.

Remember that Jesus did all of life in our place—died the death we deserved but also lived the life we couldn’t live. We need a righteous record, and that includes the way we respond to brokenness.

Instead of lashing out, he took the lashes. Instead of defending himself, he took the ridicule. Instead of returning evil for evil, he returned evil for good.

You know why?

Because you need someone to do that in your place. Because you have responded poorly admit brokenness and hurt, just like I have. I have lashed out. I have returned evil for evil. I have not responded well to being misunderstood. I have harshly judged those in my family when, at the end of the day, I’m just as sinful as they are.

Jesus not only gets it, he obeyed and responded rightly in my place so I could have a perfect record before the Father.

 So here’s your good news this Christmas:

Jesus did family brokenness in your place. He responded the ways you should have, but didn’t. He has forgiven in the ways that maybe you haven’t yet. He never slipped into a bad pattern with family discussions, but instead, always replied appropriately.

That’s great news. Why? Because if you have Jesus’ record instead of your own, God looks at you like you have responded perfectly over all these years! Can you believe that?

Let the rich and unfathomable grace roll over you this holiday season—God himself came from a line of misfits and was even rejected by his hometown, yet responded perfectly to it, in my place, for me. 

Hometowns are hard, my friend, apparently even for God in the flesh.

He gets it and he’s already responded well to it on your behalf, even when you didn’t deserve it. Now go live in that and love your crazy family and your hard hometown, even if they don’t deserve it. For this is the way God loves us. Yes, this is the way of the cross.

The Christmas picture I now cling to has nothing to do with trees or cider. It’s a simple picture, but a profound one: Jesus in my place, even over the holidays.



Thanks for stopping by the blog! If you’d rather be updated via email when a new blogpost goes live, just hit me up below for my super-minimal-non-spammy email updates!  


Join the Faith in Prose Newsletter
You will be the FIRST to know when a new blog post goes live as well as stay informed on upcoming events!
100% Privacy and I will never ever spam.